What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Dec. 21 2009 - 11:03 am | 19 views | 0 recommendations | 13 comments

Will the cloture vote drama sink Obamacare?

eyeDid Congress pass Obamacare at 1:00 a.m. this morning? One could be forgiven for thinking so. But one would be wrong. Today’s vote was only a cloture vote to shut off debate. But months of vigorous opposition by the American people and a civil war in the Democrat Party has raised the profile of the legislation to unprecedented heights in the public eye. The cloture vote was widely reported to be ‘the’ vote. To ‘Kerry’ something is no longer a safe hiding place. If a Senator tries to Kerry this thing by telling his constituents that he ‘voted for it before he voted against it,’ people will just chuckle and tell him he isn’t fooling anyone.

So the cloture vote was a vote for Obamacare.

But what comes next? We know who took the bribes in exchange for their vote. We know the blowback on sellouts like Ben Nelson has been swift and fierce.

Senator Nelson, we see you.

We know that some Democrats like Jim Webb (D-Va), crowed about bravely bucking their party by voting with Republicans to reinstate Medicare cuts, and then, less than a week later, made a craven, duplicitous, and disingenuous vote in favor of cloture.

Senator Webb, we see you.

Then there were those five Democrat Senators, Evan Bayh, Maria Cantwell, Amy Klobuchar, Blanche Lincoln, and Ben Nelson, who voted for Mike Crapo’s (R-Idaho) amendment to send the bill back to Committee to certify that individuals making less than $200,000.00 and families making less than $250,000.00 per year would not have their taxes raised, per President Obama’s campaign pledge. Their votes were an attempt to make them look honest and fiscally responsible to the voters back home. Their cloture votes today expose them as utter frauds.

Senators Bayh, Cantwell, Klobuchar, Lincoln, and (again) Nelson, we see you.

The polls show that a majority of Americans oppose the bill by a 14 point margin. Scott Rasmussen’s Approval Index poll measures the difference between those who strongly approve of the president’s performance versus those who strongly dissaprove. This morning, Obama was at 43% disapproval, the highest of his presidency.

The point is that the health care debate is not over. The final votes have not been cast. The Senate needs to pass its final bill. Then the vastly different House and Senate bills will have to go to conference to be cobbled into one bill. There will then be a final vote in the House and another cloture vote in the Senate before we get to a bill Obama can sign.

The most significant thing about the Senate cloture vote this morning was not that it passed. It was that it showed how low the Democrats were willing to go to pass it. It showed the American people that Senators like Ben Nelson, Mary Landrieu, et al., actually have no principles and can be bought. It showed that the bill has no bipartisan support and was rammed through in the middle of the night on Christmas week.

The vote will not strengthen the bill. Support will continue to erode. Polls will continue to plunge. Obama’s approval rating will hit new lows. And then will come the final votes. If the Democrats decide to stick with the bill even in that environment, we will know they do not care about the American people. And they will be treated accordingly at the polls in 10 months.

Members of the House and Senate: We see you.

Photo credit: Look into my Eyes


Active Conversation
4 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 13 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    The polls are not telling the whole story.

    I believe that the polls reflect a disapproval of the senate bill because it does not have a buy in for medicare or a public option. That is why I support Dean’s option of killing this bill and going for reconciliation where bribes would not be necessary.

  2. collapse expand

    Just for the record, nobody has forgotten what the GOP has done to mislead the public on this bill at every step of the way. Whether death panels or suddenly pretending to appear as the party that supports Medicare, you should remember…
    We see you too.

  3. collapse expand

    The simple fact is that no matter where you fall on the party lines, Democrat or Republican (or Independent), the voice of the everyday American isn’t being magnified by those we voted into office. The debate should be about how we are being represented, not about what the bill does in terms of pork for each state represented.

  4. collapse expand

    Classic. The Dems, for all their screw-ups during the past year, are on the cusp of passed meaningful HCR despite wholesale, unconditional opposition from the GOP and they accuse the Democrats of obstinate partisanship.

    Sometimes I read your feed here as satire Mr. Dupray. I really can’t follow your writing without some levity.

  5. collapse expand

    Mr. Dupray,

    Your “Senator Webb, we see you” rhythm had, probably unintentionally, had a very weird, creepy, stalker feel to it.

  6. collapse expand

    Hey Hackzilla, when are you going to comment on the disgrace of your last post re: hybrid cars?

    That hack job illustrates perfectly the M.O. of you conservative propaganda spewers. Post something containing blatantly misleading or fabricated information and expect your ignorant followers to lap it up. Since your knuckle dragging fans are too stupid to actually research an issue they form their opinions based on BS.

    Congratulations on propagating everything that is wrong with Conservatives.

    Re: Healthcare reform.

    I’ve said it a million times. We just had eight years of a Conservative administration and 6 of them with a majority in the House and never once did they care about Health Care reform.

    Now that a Democrat is in the White House Health Care reform is something they care about.

    Pathetic hypocrites.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    I am a lawyer afflicted with a consuming desire to analyze and debate politics.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 55
    Contributor Since: September 2009