What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Oct. 28 2009 - 7:14 pm | 324 views | 3 recommendations | 4 comments

Facebook: Where Huxley beats Orwell

First edition cover

Image via Wikipedia

Facebook, and other social networking sites, just may be where the dystopian nightmares of Aldous Huxley will beat out the horrors imagined by George Orwell.

In Orwell’s familiar, overdue vision Big Brother rules. A totalitarian government takes away all privacy and freedom (hard to believe, but the  1984 he envisioned would have been before many readers/writers on T/S were born).

But in Huxley’s more nuanced dystopia we willingly exchange freedom and liberty to experience a few easy pleasures. As reported this week in an excellent series on National Public Radio about online privacy, many who play around on social networking sites just may be proving Huxley prophetic in the way they trade individual rights for a little fun.

Chris Conley of the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California is particularly concerned about the quizzes that circulate on Facebook.

“These quizzes are very common,” Conley says. “If you go on Facebook you see all your friends have taken a quiz or several quizzes, depending on how much time they spend online.”

What people often don’t realize, Conley says, is that these quizzes are applications. Just like games and other entertainment, they’re programs that run in a user’s Web browser.

via Is Your Facebook Profile As Private As You Think? : NPR.

It may look  innocent enough, a quiz about 70’s pop-stars or  a horoscope application you can enjoy with a private group of selected friends. But Huxley’s trade is right there: you give up valuable and potentially damaging personal information and get a little entertainment in return.

That means your photos, political views, even sexual preferences can be sent back to the stranger who wrote the quiz application.

via Is Your Facebook Profile As Private As You Think? : NPR.

OK, but people don’t have to take these quizzes. No one is forcing them to do so. And don’t people have to explicitly agree to all these terms and conditions when they decided to use the application? Well, sort of. Despite the side effects of “soma” in Huxley’s story, like a shorter life-span, still the claim is made that is has “All the advantages of Christianity and alcohol; none of their defects.”

Look at a screen shot I pulled from the most recent version of something coming into my FB news feed.  While the screen does indeed say the application will pull profile information if you give it access, it does so accompanied by a cute little picture (imagine a skull-and-crossbones or even a sign saying “Warning – Potential Loss of Privacy”). There is also a completely uninformative, misleading statement suggesting the application will be taking the minimal information that the program “requires to work.”  It also says nothing about what it will then do with that information it takes.

Permission screen for a Facebook App

Permission screen for a Facebook App

But the problem is not just with Facebook.

Nathan Hamiel of the Hexagon Security Group has demonstrated how third-party programs could also collect information from MySpace accounts.

To him, the real problem is the false assumption of security on social networks.

“There’s a perceived safety,” he says. “People are a lot more loose with their information because they don’t realize the trust they’re putting into this application developer.”

People tend to open up about themselves on social networks, and that kind of candor is worth money. There are now companies that mine social sites for data to sell to marketers.

via Is Your Facebook Profile As Private As You Think? : NPR.

We’re blinded by the fun that is always there, just a few clicks away; “there is always soma, delicious soma.”

Of course, Orwell still may win should governments decide they too want to mine the rich veins of personal data now being collected primarily for marketing purposes. But for now, we are willingly sacrificing our rights for a few drops of techno-soma. Huxley rules.


4 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    Great post! This is one of my pet topics as well — what we willingly–though often unknowingly–give up to be entertained. You’re right, Huxley wouldn’t be surprised by what’s going on now. we have so many versions of ‘Soma’ available, Huxley’s original Soma seems quaint by comparison. My add-on to this is that part of what makes our privacy such a commodity is the saturation of media — we’re deluged to the point of not being able to track where our information is going, who we gave it to, etc. It’s like brining a cup of water with you for a swim in the ocean.

  2. collapse expand

    Hum…I guess we can scratch the phrase “Man of Mystery” from our vernacular.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    I'm a psychologist and psychoanalyst with a full-time therapy practice. Over the last 20 years I've noticed how the NEXT BIG THING, or the one after that, sometimes leaves people feeling more miserable than before; life in the "future" doesn't always feel very good by the time it gets here. But sometimes it does. We just don't know how the future will feel.

    I have been writing and lecturing to professional audiences about how our emerging technologies can change how we feel about and relate to each other, ourselves, and our bodies. Now it's time to go public.

    In case you're wondering, my clinical office is like Vegas; what's said there, stays there. How could it be otherwise? So rather than writing about individual patients, I'll be writing in general about the perils and promise we all confront as we try to build a good life in our increasingly over-simulated world. While no one knows what's coming next nor how it will make life feel, one thing I do know is that for us to thrive as individuals and a society, for us to hold on to our humanity as we become post-human, we're going to have to do it together.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 82
    Contributor Since: April 2009
    Location:New York City

    What I'm Up To

    Ever been in online therapy or e-counseling?

    Even just therapy by phone or SKYPE?

    Would you be willing to talk with me about your experience?  I want stories from the “consumer” point-of view for a professional workshop about the ethics of providing care at a distance. No information will be used without your permission.

    Click the <EMAIL ME TIPS> link above to contact me if interested.