Thank you for not commenting on my lunch
Lately, a lot of people have been telling me what to eat. This is a new development. Of course, there was a time when my parents told me what to eat, but I always thought once you got past that stage, you were on your own.
Not so. Just the other day I was having lunch with a man I had never met before, in a restaurant I suspected to be vegetarian (no meat on the menu being one clue). “I guess a diet coke would be against the rules here,” I said to the waiter, who said yes, but he would carbonate the water if I liked. (Do I look like Bozo the Clown?)
“You can’t drink diet coke,” my dining companion said. “It has something awful in it that will give you stomach problems.”
Well, in fact, I was having stomach pains at that moment, but I suspected they were from some stringy black thing in my polenta I could not identify. I was hoping it was some form of exotic mushroom. Beyond that, I didn’t want to speculate.
But the point is, when did it become so dangerous to order food in polite company? Just a week earlier, I’d been instructed by another person I had just met not to eat sugar, dairy or wheat. Still another pointed out the murderous intent of tomatoes in a tin. On second thought, she ordered, “Don’t eat anything out of a can.”
So my heart goes out to the Arizona students suddenly placed under house arrest by the food police.
Nanci Aiken, director of Tuscon’s Children’s Success Academy for kids in kindergarten through fifth grade, has banned white flour, refined sugar, and any processed food from the school premises. Birthday cupcakes? Dream on. It’s fruit and nuts for them.
The list of banned foods is substantial – American cheese, canned fruit, flavored yogurt, white bread, peanut butter made with sugar – even Oreo cookies.
And there are no exceptions to the rule, said Nanci Aiken, the school’s director. “You don’t need a cake,” she said. “They can have nuts, or fruit.”
“I feel like the Wicked Witch of the West a lot of times, but it makes such a big difference,” she said. “When you eat sugar, especially by itself like a candy bar, you get a rush and crash. An apple will not give you instant gratification or a rush, but it lasts longer.”
I don’t doubt that the school’s director is correct in her praise of the apple, and for the most part, I support the many attempts to improve the eating habits of American youth. Michelle Obama’s White House garden? Go for it—but also note that on her daughters’ spring break, the First Lady took them to a Brooklyn pizza parlor known for lines around the block.
No, Michelle is smart enough to know that rigid adherence to whatever is currently deemed a “healthy” diet is likely to produce a generation hell-bent on eating junk. Show me the four-year-old who’s denied any sweets at all, and I’ll show you the kid throwing up in the corner, the first chance he gets to overdose on chocolate.
So here is what I wish for those students in Arizona, deprived as they are of such grammar school staples as Girl Scout Cookies and Hostess Cupcakes: Learn to love whole grains and vegetables, legumes and nuts, fish and herbal tea. Every so often, allow yourself an unhealthy treat. But when you go out to eat with somebody else…keep your judgments off his plate.


















See Older Posts



