What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.
 

Apr. 22 2009 - 4:47 pm | 3 views | 0 recommendations | 3 comments

He Took Her Identity, He Tweeted, Now He Talks

Restaurant Girl

On April 10th, I got an email from someone named Adam Robb. He was responding to a posting I had written about famous food folks who twitter, some real and some fake. Adam was one of the fakes. He tweets under the name “restaurantgirl.” In the section on Twitter where you put your name, he has written his as Danyelle Freeman.

In response to my posting, Adam wrote “I never intended to confuse anyone, I really thought from the first Tweet that people would know it’s a joke, that they didn’t seems to say a lot about their expectations of the real RG.”

Meant to be a parody of the Daily News food critic Restaurant Girl, the real Danyelle Freeman apparently does not think this is funny at all and has sent the real Adam (whose name is actually Adam Robb Rucinsky) a cease & desist letter from a fancy Beverly Hills law firm.  The letter states: “Please be advised that our client has no record of having granted rights to the Trademark or the use of Freeman’s name and likeness in connection therewith.”

Adam and I have been emailing back and forth since he first wrote to me. In one email he acknowledged that Danyelle is likely not into his take on her, “I guess she would be mad but she’s really an inspiration. I’m a writer first and a foodie second and I just think this character of RestaurantGirl she developed is full of such untapped potential so when I mock, I mock RG and not Danyelle Freeman.”

Adam, as restaurantgirl, currently has 362 followers on Twitter, including two New York Times writers. (By the time you read this, the number of followers will have changed).

pete-wells-reg-12

This morning, one of those writers, Kim Severson bestowed fame on the 30-year-old New Jersey microblogger with a sizeable article in the New York Times dining section. So, I called Adam to get his take on being in the spotlight.

“I don’t know what to make of it” Adam said.  He was excited for his family and friends to see the story about him. Now that he may get sued, will he stop tweeting as Restaurant Girl?  “No. Maybe when it gets old and isn’t as fresh.” Has he ever met or spoken with Danyelle Freeman? “Never met her. Never spoken with her. ”  He does wonder when that day will come when he gets trapped in an elevator with her. What would he say to her? “ That she is an inspiration to me. If she really cares about what she’s doing and isn’t doing it for the money, then she should be flattered.” He does link to her articles in his tweets. Why? “So she can get the advertising clicks.” Adam defends his choice to parody Restaurant Girl and actually puts the blame on her. “She chose to become a public figure, rather than reviewing anonymously. If she hadn’t put her photo and didn’t want to be known… no other restaurant critic does that.” He is also critical of Danyelle’s writing. “She traded access for quality. And I just think it’s funny she has an editorial staff of five to write four posts a week – her writers even follow the RG Twitter – and yet it’s overwhelmed by false information, like saying Junior’s is in Queens and not Brooklyn, and littered with typos and grammatical errors that never get noticed.”

Ironically, Adam says he would have ceased writing immediately if Danyelle had reached out to him in the beginning. “ If she had contacted me personally and said this hurts my feelings, I would have stopped.” On Adam’s home Twitter page he adds: This Twitter is an unaffiliated parody of Danyelle Freeman, the real Restaurant Girl who can be found at restaurantgirl.com. She’s not this clever or ambitious.

Is it a parody? Is it even funny? Should people be allowed to take on other people’s identities for their own gain? Should Twitter police the fakes? Adam’s postings are somewhat innocent, but at times cruel and mocking. Why can’t Adam be funny as Adam?  And do followers feel betrayed when they realize they are following someone who isn’t the “real deal.” I have followed and unfollowed Adam as restaurantgirl a few times. I, for one, felt weird when I first discovered he was not she. However, once the food blogs started writing about the fake RG, I became more intrigued. But, honestly, I’d be super peeved if someone started writing as me.

RG Tweet


Comments

One T/S Member Comment Called Out, 3 Total Comments
Post your comment »
 
  1. collapse expand

    You should compare my real twitter account (http://twitter.com/cheeky_geeky) with my (brilliant) fake one, not run by me in any way (http://twitter.com/fakecheekygeeky) – In this case, the parody is very much like a roast: funny, biting, and respectful, and with in-depth knowledge of the subject.

    In other cases like the White House and the Lama, the account was used for deception, even if the intent was good.

  2. collapse expand

    Is it a parody? Is it even funny?

    No on both counts.

    It’s appropriation of identity, pure and simple. Also, if any of his actions made the real person look ridiculous, or he created a misperception about them, he’s open to a lawsuit that’ll tear out his funnybone for good.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook
 

My T/S Activity Feed

 
     

    About Me

    I am a food fanatic. Sardines, raw shrimp, white anchovies are just a few things that make me happy. I love that “ah moment” when you bite into something so delicious you have to pause before you can speak. Hopefully, you know what I mean. As a former Food Network host and producer, I have been given an All Access Pass into the culinary world and count many in the food community my close friends. I applaud their passion and dedication. And, I am willing to admit, I’m a bit chef-obsessed. As a culinary junkie, I follow food stories from around the globe; I am enticed by the wonderful, the weird, the sweet, and the savory. As for my background, I've worked as a producer and/or host with NBC, ABC, CBS, PBS, VH1, A Current Affair, Food Network, BBC-A, Fine Living, Showtime, Direct TV, and now, People.com.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 83
    Contributor Since: December 2008
    Location:New York City

    What I'm Up To

    FindEatDrink.com

    twitter_icon_whiteThe Insider Guide to Food + Drink

    Find. Eat. Drink. is for those who love the thrill of discovery, especially when it comes to all things eating and drinking. For us, it’s not about the hottest and latest; it’s about seeking out unique and authentic gems. How do we find them? We ask industry insiders – the people who make their living working in the culinary world – chefs, restaurateurs, bakers, bartenders, purveyors, and artisans.

    We do the homework, so you don’t have to.

    Find. Eat. Drink. – your insider food and drink guide.


    Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/FindEatDrink