What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Jul. 26 2010 - 1:24 pm | 318 views | 0 recommendations | 6 comments

SB1070 Watch | Bust narco-traffickers, not maids

Alberto Gonzalez stands outside the Arizona St...

Image by AFP via @daylife

Arizona, where I live, has become ground zero in one of the most divisive issues of our day: immigration. There are two reasons for this unfortunate distinction.

On the surface, the element that gave the issue traction here was passage of SB1070. The new law, which is due to go into effect on Thursday, would compel law enforcement officials to check the immigration status of individuals who they “reasonably suspect” of being in the U.S. illegally.

The second, and deeper, reason for Arizona’s role is political. Support for SB1070 has become a litmus test for conservatives and particularly for the far-right. The law has galvanized the small but active white supremacist movements here, who have donated money to Governor Jan Brewer’s fund to fight legal challenges to the law, and begun armed patrols near the border with Mexico. The political pressure to embrace SB1070 has become so intense that Barry Wong, a Republican running for re-election to the state commission that regulates utilities, promises to go even further and prevent utilities from selling electricity to undocumented aliens.

With bizarre anti-immigrant proposals like Wong’s now part of mainstream discourse in Arizona, Francis Fukuyama’s thoughtful piece in today’s Wall Street Journal is a much-needed antidote to the toxic politics of the day.

Fukuyama’s argument is that we must have a more nuanced understanding of the issues if we want to solve the real problem of illegal immigration: crime.

Yes, people crossing the border into the U.S. are, by definition, committing a crime. That is vastly different, however, from the notion that once here, they live the lives of criminals. Most immigrants, documented and undocumented, come here to work and to give their children a chance at a better life.

“The gardeners and maids and busboys,” Fukuyama writes, “are indeed breaking the law. But they are in a very different category from the tattooed Salvatrucha gang member who lives by extortion and drug-dealing.”

The broad-brush approach demagogued by Brewer, Wong and Senator John McCain, has nothing to do with reducing crime and border violence and everything to do with stirring up fears to get votes. It is a sad fact that politics, not logic, funnels resources. The pro-SB1070 crowd will take money that could be used to fight narco-traffickers and direct it to identifying, incarcerating and deporting people who, at worst, are guilty of over-pruning, inadequate vacuuming and failure to clear a table with all deliberate speed.

The people of Arizona would be better served by politicians who actually want to fight violent crime, than by demagogues who will settle for the farce of hunting down “illegals” and declaring “Mission Accomplished.”

The problem of gangs and drug violence should not be confounded with the behavior of the vast majority of illegal immigrants to the U.S., who by and large are seeking the same thing that every immigrant to America has wanted since the time of the Mayflower: to better their condition and that of their families. They are not criminals in the sense of people who make a living by breaking the law. They would be happy to live legally, but they come from societies in which legal rules were never quite extended to them. They are therefore better described as “informal” rather than “illegal.”

via Immigrants and Crime: Time for a Sensible Debate – WSJ.com.


Active Conversation
One T/S Member Comment Called Out, 6 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    You are 100% correct.

    This law does nothing to combat actual illegal border crossings. It’s like trying to fix a leak in a dam by mopping up the water down stream.

    The fear, hatred and outright bigotry being generated by the right wing these days, whether directed at Latinos or Muslims, is embarrassing. Trying to explain these people to non-Americans is like having to apologize for your senile grandfather who keeps peeing in the potted plants at the office Christmas party. There’s not much you can say to make it understandable.

  2. collapse expand

    If this site were visited by more people and if anyone besides his stylist knew who the author is I’d spend more time on this. So, you’ll just have to trust me that he’s being very, very misleading.

    The issue here isn’t just crimes directly committed by illegal aliens or by those on the border. It also involves crimes they commit at their destinations (which might be Maine or Washington state or NYC) and it also includes the crimes committed by their descendants. It’s odd how those like Osha Gray Davidson don’t mention the 2nd and 3rd generations.

    Nor do they mention the issue of corruption; there’s a good chance that some or many local officials on the border are on the take.

    Those like Osha Gray Davidson (and actual members of the elite like Fukuyama) want to sit on their verandas while darker-complected folks work in the fields, despite the damage done to both the U.S. and Mexico.

  3. collapse expand

    ON THE SURFACE – I don’t even need to read anything more. Bullcrap. Was the murder of the rancher “on the surface”? Are the heavy fire power drug wars taking place just across from Laredo “on the surface”? Is the trafficking of human beings “on the surface”? Are the piles of trash on the Arizona border “on the surface”? Are the thousands of illegals sucking up our tax payer dollars “on the surface”? Are the mothers coming here to have their anchor babies for free “on the surface”? Are the criminal illegal immigrants being let out of jail over and over “on the surface”? Are the illegal immigrants being deported and turning around and coming back over and over “on the surface”? The deeper issue is NOT POLITICS. It’s POLITICS that have allowed your “on the surface” issue to become a National TRAVESTY

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    I'm an investigative reporter and author living in the northern Sonoran Desert (Phoenix). I've been a regular contributor to Rolling Stone, Mother Jones, New York Times, LA Times, Salon, The Nation, and many other national publications.

    In addition to my Solar Plexus, I'm a correspondent for OnEarth (the NRDC's magazine), contributor to several other online sites, and publisher and editor of El Phoenix Sun, a blog covering solar power and environmental news from the American Southwest.

    I'm addicted to #twitter. Please #help me #score by #following @thephoenixsun.

    I've written several screenplays. One of them actually made it to the screen; the IMAX documentary, "Coral Reef Adventure."

    My books reflect either my eclectic interests or a short attention span, depending on whether you believe me or my wife:

    Broken Heartland (Farm crisis and rural issues)

    Under Fire (The NRA and gun control)

    The Best of Enemies (Race, class and redemption in the New South)

    The Enchanted Braid (Coral reefs)

    Fire in the Turtle House (Sea turtles and ocean issues)

    Enchanted by Prairie (The original Midwest ecosystem)

    For more:

    www.oshadavidson.com, www.thephoenixsun.com, and (always) @thephoenixsun

    See my profile »
    Followers: 44
    Contributor Since: August 2009
    Location:Phoenix, AZ

    What I'm Up To

    Editing my photographs of the Arizona Anti-Immigration Law rally. (Below: Srta. Libertad)