‘Idol’ places its bets, and its power, behind Lee Dewyze
Rabid Crystal Bowersox fans (and, admittedly, I lead that pack) better brace yourself:
“American Idol” has picked its winner — and it’s not the MamaSox of our dreams.
If last night’s “Idol” had one clear message for us (other than that the producers desperately want Casey James to lose) it’s this… and it was unmistakable in its clarity. “Idol” is going to do everything it can to make sure Lee Dewyze takes home the crown.
The evidence was stark:
1. In picking songs for the remaining three contestants, the judges (particularly Ellen Degeneres) saddled Crystal with “Maybe I’m Amazed,” a very nice but somewhat slight song from Vegetarian-in-Chief and former Wings frontman Sir Paul McCartney. MamaSox sang the hell out of it, and it was nice to see her stepping out of her mic-stand-and-strumming-guitar milieu to focus completely on showcasing her voice — which is even more elastic than I’d realized. But, like I said, it’s a nice song… but not a showstopper. Crystal did everything she could with it, but ultimately, you can’t build a lasting cathedral out of Play-Doh.
2. And while Crystal walked the stage alone, Lee was given a somber chorus of black-clad background singers who emerged dramatically from a blinding tunnel of white light behind him halfway through his version of Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah.” So, beyond even the show’s producers setting him up with an arresting bit of stagecraft and choreography, judge Simon Cowell gave him a drama-drenched song to sing — one that is usually the Hail Mary last resort of contestants who know they’re just a few votes away from slipping back into obscurity. To his credit, Lee made the most of it — no doubt he’s got talent — but it just seemed like Simon and the producers were giving him every tool he needed to close the show in stunning fashion.
3. It’s become clear whose backstory the show’s producers have glommed on to. Lee’s victory in two weeks would be the fitting culmination to a Hollywood rags-to-riches story to rival that of Lana Turner having a Coke at the counter at Schwab’s (which, Wikipedia tells me, isn’t even completely true! We’ve all been living a lie!)
How many times last night — and in previous weeks — has host Ryan Seacrest referred to Lee as “the paint salesman from Chicago”? Yes, Lee was an hourly employee in a paint store before he tried out for “Idol,” and, yes, his music career was… nascent, to be charitable. But the way the show repeatedly recites his humble beginnings before, with Solomon-like wisdom and Buffett-like foresight, the judges plucked him from the depths of soul-crushing obscurity and imbued him with power and confidence and be-knighted him on a pedestal of national TV fame, you’d think they’re just polishing up the story for the eventual press-releases they’ll put out rather than simply introducing a guitar player.
I half-expect next week Seacrest, his face cast in mysterious shadows, to solemnly intone, “Ladies and gentlemen… he was once a poor street urchin from the wrong side of the tracks, scratching out a feral existence based solely on whatever monetary crumbs he could steal from a subsistence living as (shudder) a lowly clerk in a retail service industry… a downtrodden and empty vessel of a schlub on whom life and Chicago had turned their backs… a friendless schnook who had to build his own guitar out of the broken pieces of used primer brushes and ate his meals from whatever leftover condiments he could slap together and stuff into an unhygienic, broke-down paint mixer… his clothes crudely stitched togther from worn out drop clothes thrown at him by angry, violent customers demanding a pound of his flesh and store credit… let’s welcome Lee Dewyze!”
Can Crystal compete with that?

















See Older Posts

