What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

May. 19 2009 - 10:26 am | 6 views | 0 recommendations | 2 comments

Tomorrow we crown a new American Idol. But the real winner is . . .?

HOLLYWOOD - APRIL 14:  American Idol Season 8 ...

Image by Getty Images via Daylife

Tonight millions of Americans will vote in an election that will best the number of ballots cast for most U.S. Presidents. Granted, there are fewer restrictions: In the battle for American Idol, voting is via phone or text; one needn’t be 18 years or older; and the electorate may vote for their candidate as many times as they like or are able to while the polls remain open.

So who will be the next American Idol? Duh: Adam Lambert.

Despite a late-innings rally, the sweet, talented but kinda boring Kris Allen will lose handily to Lambert in what will be the most lopsided final since Fantasia wiped the stage with teen cage bird Diana DeGarmo back in Season Three.

Still, it’ll be a fun show to watch, thanks in large part to the theatrical rocker with the black nail polish and unconfirmed sexuality. (Earlier in the competition, EW.com and the Los Angeles Times, among other outlets, inferred that Lambert is gay, but he played it coy during last week’s Entertainment Weekly cover story iview: ”I know who I am. I’m an honest guy, and I’m just going to keep singing.”)

But here’s the real question: Will Lambert easily transition into a bonafide pop star? Will he become a pop star at all? Or, after the confetti is cleaned up and the obligatory summer Idol tour is as distant a memory as Season Five champ Taylor Hicks, will the flamboyant fave end up on Off-Broadway in The Rocky Horror Picture Show? (Hold on a minute — that fate suited former Idol finalist Constantine Maroulis just fine: He was (shockingly) nominated for a 2009 Tony for Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Musical for 80s mock rockpera Rock of Ages, which recently upgraded from OB to the Great White Way. But then, Maroulis didn’t even make Season Four’s Top Five.)

LOS ANGELES, CA - MARCH 05:  American Idol con...

Image by Getty Images via Daylife

The truth is, Lambert certainly has what it takes to make it outside of the talent show. But if it’s longevity we’re talking about, then my money’s on Allison Iraheta, the pink-haired dark horse who came in fourth. Her rendition of “Papa Was a Rolling Stone” was a season-stealer that should have had her finale-bound. The star-making moment rather reminded me of that time, way back in Season One, when Kelly Clarkson first revealed her range on “(You Make Me Feel Like A) Natural Woman”. 

Last Saturday, I caught Clarkson’s no-frills but plenty of thrills set at New York radio station Z100’s Zootopia. And despite what this week’s tabs will no doubt say about her rather plain appearance (next-to-no makeup, unstyled hair, and less-than-flattering figure), she outshone the energetic Black Eyed Peas and their oddly costumed dancers. Why? Because she doesn’t need gimmicks — her songs and voice were the show.

That’s why, like Chris Daughtry, another Idol who didn’t come close to winning the crown but a year later won a Grammy, Iraheta will be runner-up with the career. So long as she makes the right record, the precocious, more marketable teen will best likely winner Lambert where it really counts: on the charts.


2 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 2 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    While Adam undoubtedly can sing (as Randy would say), he will need to rethink his musical approach if he wants to sell millions of records. His kind of rock-operatic theatricality went out with Meat Loaf. Personally, Adam doesn’t move me. Too pitch perfect, too rehearsed and completely lacking in spontaneity. Maybe in the finale, he’ll finally give us that real, raw, underplayed moment I’ve been waiting for. Or not. I’m holding out for Allison’s debut CD.

  2. collapse expand

    i couldn´t agree more!! Maybe the world knows that the runner up is the only one to actually follow through with a career, so it´s a sort of reverse psychology. The winner get´s lost in the mix, so give him his 5 minutes of fame and the true winner will forever be the star!!

    As far as the nail polish goes…thank god someone had a little style going on! Isn´t that what music is all about…self expression. I don´t see how that could be contsrued as a negative, when without it…what a BORE the music world will become!! xoxo sammy

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    A 16-year media executive, Lori Majewski is a founder and ex-editor-in-chief of the American Society of Magazine Editors (ASME) award-winning Teen People, and a former executive editor of Entertainment Weekly and Us Weekly. Lori is currently a partner in and Chief Content Officer of the upcoming brand launch ThisGirl, a multi-platform community that entertains and empowers women in the 16 to 30 year-old psychographic. She also recently became a member of the team behind the First-Ever Tween Girls Summit, produced by Allykatzz.com and to be held in D.C. on Oct. 10, 2009.

    After serving on Do Something’s Board of Directors, Lori joined the non-profit's staff in 2008 as their inaugural editor-in-chief. Among her varied duties: overseeing content for 2009 Webby award-winning DoSomething.org and its celebrity blog, CelebsGoneGood.com; urging celebrities to be philanthropic by persuading them to participate in Do Something campaigns and public service announcements; and coordinating 2008’s first-ever Do Something Awards in Hollywood, a walk-up event to that year's Fox Teen Choice, where $100,000 was presented on-air to the Do Something Awards grand prize winner. She recently led the talent recruitment committee for the 2009 Do Something Awards held June 4 in NYC.

    Lori heads up the New York effort for Cape Farewell, a London-based group of socially responsible artists dedicated to creating a cultural dialogue about climate change. In October 2008, Lori travelled to the High Arctic with artists such as Suzan Lori Parks, Laurie Anderson, Vanessa Carlton, KT Tunstall, Riyuchi Sakamoto, Jarvis Cocker and many others, as well as a team of internationally known oceanographers, on a 10-day expedition that was recognized by British Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

    Widely recognized as an expert in teen and popular culture, Lori has appeared on shows like Today, Good Morning America, CNN, and in the pages of USA Today, The New York Times and Rolling Stone, is a lifelong resident of Weehawken, NJ.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 12
    Contributor Since: May 2009