What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Jun. 3 2010 - 4:08 pm | 586 views | 0 recommendations | 3 comments

Will waterboarding detainees be one of George W. Bush’s ‘decision points?’

President George W. Bush took to Facebook yesterday with a new ‘Fan’ page, which can only mean one thing: he’s getting ready to prime the pump and sell his memoir.

I’m actually looking forward to Bush’s book. That’s because unlike a lot of other ghostwritten political tomes, W.’s memoir actually sounds like it will be eminently readable. In March last year a Bush aide (perhaps the ex-speechwriter who is helping him write it) told Mike Allen that the book would be “less conventional and chronological, not an exhaustive history.” Rather than mulling over all 8 years of his presidency, he’ll be narrating about a series of key decisions he made in his life, starting with his decision to give up drinking. An AP report about his book last month also explained that it would cover “the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the troop surge in Iraq, his responses to terrorists attacks and Hurricane Katrina and the financial meltdown.”

And if we’re going to talk about ‘responses to terrorists attacks’ than I think we need to know more about how President Bush reached the decision to order the torture of detainees like Khalid Sheikh Mohammed who are accused of assisting al Qaida in carrying out the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

The problem is that whenever we hear former administration officials talk about waterboarding and other methods of torture that were authorized – including the president himself – it doesn’t sound like a great moral decision. Instead, it just seems like an obvious thing that they would do. Take the President last night at an address in Grand Rapids, Michigan:

“Yeah, we water-boarded Khalid Sheikh Mohammed,” Bush said of the terrorist who master-minded the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks on New York and Washington. He said that event shaped his presidency and convinced him the nation was in a war against terror.

“I’d do it again to save lives.”

Now let’s step aside from the debate between the reality that torture is immoral and doesn’t work and the alternate reality in which Bush ordering waterboarding yielded actionable intelligence that saved American lives. Let’s just take a look at the question of why Bush decided that it was the right thing to do to torture men captured on the global battlefield of the War on Terrorism. Bush wants us to believe that he is a thoughtful person who rationally reached conclusions about what he needed to do at various moments in his life. But when it comes to ordering a terrible, anti-American act of torture, he declares, quite simply “Yeah…I’d do it again.”

I think as a country we’re owed more than such a simple formulation of how the decision was reached to order the torture of human beings, an act that is so far beyond the pale of what it means to be a law-abiding American. The order came on down from the top, so the rationalization should also come on down from the top, including the deliberations that resulted in the rationalization. So far, the 43rd President of the USA isn’t offering it, and our shrinking violent successor in President Obama isn’t forcing his hand in any way. And if his memoir is really going to offer a set of crucial decisions, it will be missing a crucial story if it leaves this out how President Bush decided that torturing men was the right thing to do.


2 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 3 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    “…how President Bush decided that torturing men was the right thing to do.”

    This is the true kernel in the code. The debate has shifted on many axes, all of which seem to be secondary to this most appropriate of inquiries. A simple question I’ve asked of my children many times: What made you think that was right?

  2. collapse expand

    I would like someone to admit that he or she knowingly recommended techniques used by worst enemies–the Empire of Japan during WW2 and North Korean during the 1950-53 Korean War. Someone dredged these up, but failed to mention their sources, as they passed these techniques along.
    By making glib statements like this, George W. Bush is demanding an investigation and a trial, not forestalling one.

  3. collapse expand

    As a former sales exec. I had to spend time learning my product, it’s strenght , and it’s weaknesses. Then I had to learn how to pre-handle any objections to my presentation. I had to learn them “point by Point” So I know a snow job when I see one. G.Bush Had two years to put together a nice fairy tale and no doubt had aids to practice with him until he got it “right” But George, What about the abuse of americans, and torture of the same due to your veiws on privacy and the Patriot Act.? You don’t have to convince us of your points or reasons, You should thank whatever god you talk to that there are a million gullible , trusting fools out there to buy your “story”.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    I'm waiting for the day when I can get the news directly into my brain. Until then, I'll be lit up by the electric glow of screens, chasing the latest breaking like the hopeless news junkie I am. Ever since the Encyclopaedia Britannica tried to launch a web portal ten years ago, I've seen many ends of the online news spectrum, from my time as a political news reporter for both RawStory.com and the Huffington Post to the better part of a year I spent running the late New York Sun's website. There have been a lot of other stops in between. Now I am your homepage editorial overlord. But I haven't let it go to my head. Yet.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 336
    Contributor Since: November 2008
    Location:True/Slant's Mountain Lair

    What I'm Up To

    • The Morningside Post

      I’m a founding editor of The Morningside Post, the community blog for Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs


    • 2960885091_89af285ac5_moff off wall street

      where I go to write

      things too impolite

      for work

    • +O
    • +O