The blogosphere doesn’t need Pitchfork’s Altered Zones
Image via Wikipedia
Popular indie music site Pitchfork announced it will launch Altered Zones, a sister site dedicated to DIY sounds so obscure not even those on staff at Pitchfork have heard of some of the bands or dreamt up cool new tags for the zany new tunes. Pitchfork has some lofty goals for the site, which will premier online July 7:
Uniting an international team of bloggers whose individual sites have proven among the most consistently rewarding outposts for unique and leftfield music, this new site will highlight the most notable and adventurous new artists, serving as a focal point for the flood of creativity coming from deep within the music underground.
Though I don’t doubt the positive intentions behind Pitchfork’s Altered Zones, and though the idea is certainly novel, I can’t imagine anything more detrimental to the idea of the blogosphere than Altered Zones.
One of the many rewarding aspects of music blogging is the conversation that occurs among countless bloggers delving into little niches. It’s created a gorgeous kaleidoscope of perspectives on everything from American pop to Angolan hip-hop, and it’s fostered a dialogue wherein individuals are both experts on a specific sounds and newbies eager to learn about other genres.
Pitchfork, by and large, has stayed out of this conversation. The site will give credit where credit is due, linking to blogs that find the latest radio rip of a new LCD Soundsystem song or ones that post a new Animal Collective video from a European performance. But, the buck stops when it comes to the critical analysis of music. They are the authority on all things music, so why would a reader want another opinion? That authoritative voice is even a part of their editorial voice:
Launched in 1996, Pitchfork is the essential guide to independent music and beyond, and is widely regarded as the music world’s primary tastemaker.
Prior to Tuesday’s announcement, it was easy to find practically any independent blog “at war” with Pitchfork. The site is, to many, the exemplar of “the man.” And they certainly act the part. Though music is, and always has been, an individual choice, many blogs (and music writers for that matter) drew lines in the sand with specific bands.
The blogs boosted bands like Cold War Kids and Sound Team to heights previously unimagined by some dude with a domain name and love for music, and Pitchfork decimated those bands with a couple swift negative reviews. Yes, taste is in the eye of the beholder, but it wasn’t beyond some skeptical individuals to ponder the question of whether or not Pitchfork handed down these negative reviews as if to show the burgeoning blogs who’s in control.
It’s with Altered Zones that Pitchfork appears to be hijacking the conversation occurring on the music blogosphere. Pitchfork’s attitude of absolute authority in deeming certain sounds as credible has been extended to the still-unwieldy world of the blogs, and somehow the folks at Pitchfork believe they can trade some popular web space for a real, authentic blog voice with 14 popular blogging sites.
Thank goodness, the benevolent Pitchfork has arrived to pull some of our blogging brethren from the depths of this cruel CSS-fueled community! Right?
Wrong. Though I don’t doubt Pitchfork’s attempts to get the best coverage of the ever-growing music world, their ideal to provide a closed forum with their 14 favorite blogs on tap is hardly any improvement over what they are currently engaged in.
A better choice could have been a universal forum, where bloggers can submit content that a select few editors could sift through and find the best content. Even though some system like that would merely continue to validate Pitchfork’s supremacy in the modern musical conversation, it’s certainly more appealing than Pitchfork’s ill-minded presentation of the blogosphere. There are hundreds of thousands of music blogs covering valid musical content: To say only 14 blogs, no matter how popular and well-conceived they are, is an absolute fallacy.
Then again, this could be a good thing for music. Not in terms of the music being covered by Altered Zones, although I’m sure there will be artists with great voices that receive some well-deserved exposure on the site. It could be a good thing for the evolution of alternative and independent music not being covered by Altered Zones.
The history of alternative music has been one of an underground culture ignored by the critical elite, allowed to fester and grow in the corners of basements and find audiences in zines. Those zines are now the countless blogs waiting to be discovered, those basements are filled by bands simply not covered by Pitchfork’s all-knowing hand. And 14 hand-picked blogs can’t be expected to cover everything, especially when Pitchfork’s editorial voice has made an effort to ignore certain aspects of modern music.
Sure, if I want the latest Wavves sound-alike or a Wu-Tang Clan solo project, I’ll go to Gorilla vs. Bear. But, if I want a spec of info on current world electronic and hip-hop, I’ll go to wayne&wax. If I want anything metal-related, I’ll see what former Pitchfork-writer Brandon Stosuy is up to. Experimental and noise? Anti-Gravity Bunny. Emo? Certainly not Pitchfork, or any of the Altered Zones-related blogs for that matter. And I’ll take Algernon Cadwallader over Real Estate any day of the week.
So, what’s the fear? Well, Pitchfork does have pull. And the idea that they can claim to present the only reputable voices on the blogosphere is less dangerous for bloggers than music listeners. Technology has made instant gratification not only easy to achieve, but a desired goal. By aggregating a select number of blogs into a single site and using their significant pull in the music world, Pitchfork’s Altered Zones could cut music listeners’ web browsing down to size. With everything supposedly worth listening to available on a single site, why would you want to even think of exploring elsewhere? Sure, online searches are easy, but visiting a single site is even easier.
Although many blogs won’t get the Pitchfork seal-of-approval, I’ve got my fingers crossed that they will carry on without a second thought. Music bloggers have dedicated weeks, months and years to their beloved sites. Pitchfork’s sudden “validation” of a “lucky” few sites shouldn’t change things. Frankly, it shouldn’t even matter.
More on True/Slant Right Now
-
-
Related streams
Post Your Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment
T/S Members
Log in with your True/Slant account.
[...] Altered Zones. Ne avevamo davvero bisogno? (via @takethesong e @polaroid) [...]
You make some good points…but a universal forum?? There’s already Hipinion or, shit, GOOGLE for that matter. People can search far and wide to find what they want, and they’ll still be able to. This, like you said, eases peoples clicking finger in the search of something they like. This doesn’t take away CHOICE. For whatever reason, P4K liked these sites and decided to ask them to be a part of something new/fresh. An opportunity almost ANY blogger would have taken had they been asked. Of course news like this is sure to garner controversy, but damn lets see what this thing is gonna look like before people deem this irrelevant. Maybe they’ll add other “bloggers” to contribute. Maybe it will totally fail as these “bloggers” will probably be subject to deadlines. Who knows, but I’m excited to see how this turns.
Excellent points yourself. And yes, I too am curious to see what the actual site looks like. As I said at the top of this post, I’m not against the idea, I just feel the attitude taken with this project negates the communicative environment of the music blogosphere.
In response to another comment. See in context »Yeah…I do see how this is probably viewed upon as “cliquish”. Well, it kinda is ha! Could be the start of segregation and Jim Crow Blog Law. Or even gangs. Imagine turf wars: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u05Qot_yh9c
Hey Leor –
I dig your blog and check your posts here on T/S from time to time.
This post is completely not constructive in the least, but coming from an impassioned music lover, I fucking hate Pitchfork. It is run by the worst types of snobbish, verbose nincompoops that are so concerned with being contrarian that they forget to ever make any emotional connection with any music whatsoever. Not to mention, many of the authors write as if they have no idea how music actually functions as an auditory experience, focusing more of what side project this or that idiot is currently working on. I’ve listened to the records they rank the highest in their album reviews; a number of them are unlistenable. I have literally wondered aloud while reading their posts if they are playing a huge joke on their readership, a giant Emporer’s-New-Clothes type gag where they’ve managed to dredge the shittiest muck they can fish out of the sea of indie music, label it as the most brilliant sound since the phonograph and with a snarky, ironic grin ask their drone army of skinny jean clad readers, “Don’t you get it too?” I can only hope that this latest attempt to include the blogosphere is a a sign that these pretentious morons are losing traffic and desperately attempting to stay relevant to keep the ad revenue rolling in. If by the grace of god I’m right, I hope they fail.
[...] “It’s with Altered Zones that Pitchfork appears to be hijacking the conversation occurring on the music blogosphere,” says True/Slant [...]
[...] The blogosphere doesn't need Pitchfork's Altered Zones [...]
I don’t agree with you on some points. A lot of people dedicate extensive time and energy into finding new music online, and a lot of people have other stuff going on in their lives. People like me, who add new music to their ipods maybe once a month, are still a minority when it comes to music fans in general. Most people have their itunes library set in stone and don’t know how to navigate the internet to discover new artists (or simply don’t give a f*ck about staying up to date with in the music world). Pitchfork.com makes it pretty easy to find new artists with their ranking system, but I would say I only really enjoy about 25% of what they consider AMAZING music. But of that 25%, I’ve discovered some of my favorite artists to date.
I became exposed to Altered Zones because I’m a regular reader of Pitchfork. Of everything that Pitchfork wanks, I like the chillwave stuff the most. I smoke pot, I like laid back music, and I like the nostalgic feel. So, instead of sifting through artsy fartsy noise puke that some individual writer on Pitchfork thinks is amazing, I can go on Altered Zones, pack a bowl, and sift through laid back psychedelic stuff that I’m much more likely to enjoy.
But the main reason I’m disagreeing with your points is that as a “less dedicated” music fan, I didn’t even know the “art” of navigating the music blogosphere until Altered Zones was launched. Seeing the daily updates on their site, in the “blogspot” format (with the trippy 80’s psychedelic aesthetic that I love), was new to me when the website first launched. And those 14 blogs that you claim are so limiting, are actually very liberating for someone like me. Instead of relying on Pitchfork’s numerical ranking system, I can now find a blog that I like (I like Altered Zones and the “vibe” they are going for), and check it randomly. And this is currently opening me up to finding new bloggers whose musical tastes I can trust. Just by being exposed to those 14 bloggers, I’m probably going to discover many more blogs, and many more from that. By saying Pitchfork’s endorsement of a BLOGGY website is LIMITING people’s musical discovery doesn’t make sense to me, since so many people like myself ONLY read Pitchfork because it’s simple and straight to the point. If anything, them endorsing a REAL music blog helps expose simpletons like me who only check out the “best new musics” once in a while. To a blogmaster like yourself, it might seem bad, but I think people on your “level” don’t need to worry about being limited by this. People on my “level” are just discovering that there are several more artists out there aside from the ones that P4k wanks, and many more methods of discovery.
[...] offended by the whole idea of a Pitchfork-sponsored blog on experimental music – and some people most certainly are — there’s no denying that there’s some interesting stuff to be found on Altered Zones, [...]