What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.
 

Nov. 19 2009 - 6:59 am | 569 views | 1 recommendation | 10 comments

Hippocrates Health Institute: Five reasons not to spend $4,000

A conventionalized image in a Roman "port...

Image via Wikipedia

Last week, a friend of mine came back from a two-week holiday looking a little too thin, a touch too pale and more exhausted than rejuvenated. After our six-mile run turned into a one-mile speed-walk before she stopped at a park bench, I remarked on her fatigue.

“Jet-lagged?” I asked.

“No,” she said. “Hippocrates.”

Turns out that the girl – a fellow runner and vegan, with, I’m sorry to admit, an irksome blind faith in myths like lemon tea cleanses and the power of positive thinking – had just spent two weeks at the Hippocrates Health Institute. There, she underwent a myriad of cleansing processes, followed a strict all-raw all-alkali diet and spent most of her evenings curled up in a very hungry fetal position. She booked the trip – which ran $4,000 not including her flight – because she’d been feeling burnt out. And now?

“I feel like shit.”

I’m all for alternative health practices, when there’s evidence to suggest that they can help (yoga, meditation, and – maybe – acupuncture), but any “retreat” that leaves one feeling worse than they did upon entering is subject to some serious Extreme Self investigation. The Hippocrates Health Institute is a compound in West Palm Beach, FL, that was founded five decades ago and based on the Hippocratic adage “Let food be thy medicine.” Pretty sure he wasn’t talking about coconut milk and wheatgrass, but that’s what the HHI advocates. Especially wheatgrass. They love wheatgrass. So much that they often shove it where they ought not to. Allow me to explain, by offering you five reasons to avoid making the mistake of my good friend. Who, if you were wondering, is going to Vegas this weekend – another kind of detox.

1. That wheatgrass thing

I don’t doubt that wheatgrass is probably alright for you. Most green, from-the-soil, plant-based foods are. But there’s been no proof – absolutely none – that wheatgrass can cure cancer, prevent diabetes or grow back human hair. And, of course, it also tastes like grass. No need for proof in West Palm Beach, apparently, because the HHI is big on wheatgrass: “In our programs, the juice is consumed orally, and used in enemas and rectal implants.” Relax. If you’re more of a straight-up enema devotee, they also offer them in “Original” and “Coffee” varieties.

2. Would you trust Geraldo with your personal health?

HHI employs over a dozen full-time staff members. There’s Michael, the greenhouse manager, who grows tray after tray of “the lifeblood” of rectal implants. Jolene Jackson, the spa director, who apparently has 17 years experience in spa therapy, despite not looking a day over 21 (must be the wheatgrass). And then there’s Scott, the general program director for the entire holistic trainwreck. Among Scott’s resume padding is “hands-on work” with Geraldo Rivera. I don’t want to get melodramatic or theatrical here, but I think health and Geraldo in the same sentence is pretty much a deal-breaker for me.

3. Devastating illness + wheatgrass = Fail

If you were under the impression that the HHI was little more than a very eccentric spa, allow me to correct you. The Institute also purports to treat “devastating illnesses” – you know, like cancer, heart disease and HIV/AIDS. It all comes down to “live blood cell analysis,” which is basically the process of checking out a drop of blood underneath a dark-field microscope. That’s followed by drinking an ounce of wheatgrass (but seriously, that’s what they do) and seeing one’s blood miraculously revitalize.

Live blood cell analysis has long been associated with quack medicine, and isn’t even legal in many states. From a professor of Complementary Medicine at the University of Exeter: “the bulk of this money is made not through charging for the test itself but by selling expensive nutritional supplements…with the promise that these will correct whatever abnormality has been diagnosed.” Expensive supplements, like, say, a $180 bottle of something called Yings-Tea Y Caps?

4. As if $4,000 wasn’t bad enough

When you spend $200 for an afternoon at the spa, or a really nice haircut, do you ever find that you leave having spent a few extra bucks on gel, lotion or callus removal cream? Exactly. Spend $4,000 for a week at HHI, and you’ll probably be so jazzed about wheatgrass and your shit-free colon that you’ll head over to their conveniently located shop for a few goodies. Were you looking for a BioPro Cell Chip to treat your electro-pollution? Yes, they have that. A $450 juicer for at-home wheatgrass? Yup. Enema syringes specially designed for infants? Oh my god. A crockpot? Uh, somehow yes. A Hippocrates baseball cap? Seriously, they also have that.

5. And then there’s the “food”

In the description of their program curriculum, the HHI describes their classes on food preparation, a process they refer to as “cooking” (quotation marks included). There’s a big difference between cooking and “cooking” – and therein lies the problem. And then there’s the overarching HHI definition of food itself:

Food, according to Webster’s Dictionary, is any substance that enables one to live and grow — anything that nourishes. Based on this definition, hardly anything in the standard Western diet can be considered food!

Hardly anything? Confusing, because I’ve been living and growing pretty well on a lot of things – many of them cooked – for over two decades now. My alkaline-acid balance might of out-of-whack, and my enzymes might be releasing negative bio-energy into my kidneys, but hell – at least I’m not living off spelt tortillas and sea-sar salad.


Comments

Active Conversation
2 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 10 Total Comments
Post your comment »
 
  1. collapse expand

    I agree with HHI on many of their beliefs, but it seems as though the “lifeblood” of their treatment is a tad all encompassing with their bogus claims of curative properties for some of them. Additionally, wheatgrass is their ingredient of choice for all of their treatments due to it’s ease of growing and relative low cost. I can totally visualize the “farmer” dude preparing tray upon tray of wheatgrass seed, awaiting their germination day after day.

  2. collapse expand

    Sure, I think nutrition can be a very valuable “medicinal” tool. You can’t deny how many illnesses it has been linked to, either as a causative factor or preventative one. I think the raw foodist perspective takes it a little far, though, especially given the absence of scientific evidence to support raw food over plain old nutritious cooked food.

    Good point about the cost of wheatgrass – I didn’t think of that. Hmm…suspicious.

  3. collapse expand

    This is funny. As rational and skeptical as I like to think I am, I am very susceptible to these alternative health miracle ideas. I know so much is placebo effect, but that’s still an effect, right? But really, thanks for the wake-up call.

    -Matt

  4. collapse expand

    Matt – I know the feeling. It can be hard, when I so often write about this stuff, not to buy into it. Actually, on a somewhat related note, I swear by OxySox for any run longer than 3 miles. Do they do anything? No idea. But what if I don’t wear them and injure myself?

    …But I’d rather buy some $20 socks than some $4,000 enemas.

  5. collapse expand

    Since I have a reputation for living a “healthy lifestyle”, I’ve had a few family members and friends ask me about detox teas, cleanses, and even those special strips you wear on the bottom of your feet to remove toxins. To be honest, I think most of that stuff is a hoax. The human body is amazingly complex and I think the kidneys and liver do a pretty good job keeping things clean.

    I’m always skeptical of people who say they have “so much energy” when they go on cleanses. I’m pretty sure I’d be hibernating in bed if all I could subsist on was raw veggies and lemon juice. some nights I get less sleep than I should and I do have a cup of coffee every morning, but so far I think my energy levels are workin’ out pretty well for me, no $4000 spa weekend needed. Interesting topic though, that’s for sure!

    -Megan

  6. collapse expand

    All you need is leafy greens for good health, you should know that Katie. :P

    -Utz

  7. collapse expand

    Megan: I’ve never met someone who felt good after/during a cleanse. But I don’t get out much. My sister always tries cleanses and then gives up and eats fries.

    And can you imagine how far $4,000 could get you at an actual, relaxation-oriented spa? Now that would be cleansing…

  8. collapse expand

    I just spent 15 months living in Spain where my diet consisted of pork, cheese, beer and olives; not once was something shot up my ass. Next time I have $4,000 again, I think I’ll go back to the Spanish detox.

  9. collapse expand

    Katie strikes again, and that’s a compliment. You are so pure, at least by my standards, me–who eats almost every food that’s healthy and almost every food that’s not. But your healthy ways are never overbearing, and you speak out clearly against faux healthiness. Even on my worst compulsive overeating days, I feel cleansed (in the good sense) reading your prose.

  10. collapse expand

    Oh – Steve – thank you! I do eat mostly healthy food, I guess, but it is also food I enjoy. And, that being said, I just finished a bag of microwave popcorn…I think a little of this and a little of that is the way to go. And that goes for wheatgrass, too!

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook
 

My T/S Activity Feed

 
 

About Me

I'm a full-time heath & science writer at Sphere and a contributing editor at True/Slant. I also contribute military health news to Danger Room at Wired.com, and have recently written for Marie Claire, World Politics Review and Next American City.

My first foray into journalism came in middle school - at a French-speaking plaid-kilt-wearing educational institute somewhere in the Canadian tundra. It was there that I decided to start my own newspaper, to disseminate my sarcasm and attitude problem among my peers. We lasted three issues.

From there I started to freelance, and when I became a medium-sized fish in a small Canadian lake, I decided to move to New York, and become a spore in a vast journalistic ocean. The adventure continues.

I try to parallel my personal interests with my professional work - so most of my writing has some connection to health, science and animal rights.

Email me Extreme story ideas at

katiedrumm@gmail.com

You can also find me:

At Danger Room on Wired's website.

Or on Twitter @katiedrumm.

Otherwise, I'm either triathloning, eating, breaking my pelvis, or sleeping. Extreme, I know.

See my profile »
Followers: 184
Contributor Since: May 2009
Location:N to the YC

What I'm Up To

  • Danger Room at Wired.com

    wired-logo-2I contribute coverage of the military medical beat at Wired.com

     
  • World Politics Review

    3818788252_e035c9a711I contribute military/defense coverage to World Politics Review

     
  • On Twitter

    twitter_logo_header-2

     
.<
  • +O
  • +O
  • +O
>.