What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Feb. 3 2010 - 4:18 pm | 49 views | 0 recommendations | 2 comments

The American Idol Challenge: Is There Life After Simon?

Simon Cowell at the National Television Awards...

Image via Wikipedia

God help American Idol! This season, the producers already had to replace original judge Paula Abdul. Now with the debut of Ellen Degeneres only one week away (Tuesday, February 9), the Idol powers that be are already faced with the monumental task of finding the next Simon Cowell, who’s leaving when his contract expires at the end of this, the ninth season, to launch the U.S. version of the hit UK star search The X Factor.

Suddenly, discovering America’s next pop superstar seems so much easier.

Well, replacing Simon Cowell is about to get easier, too. Simon Fuller, if you’re reading, here are 10 suggestions.

Elton John He’s gone diva to diva with George Michael and Tina Turner as well as Edina Monsoon and Patsy Stone (remember his deliciously cranky cameo on Absolutely Fabulous?), and by God, he’s still standing. If anyone can outbitch Simon, it’s Sir Elton Hercules John.

Rosie O’Donnell Rosie Vs. Kara DioGuardi. Enough said.

Elaine Paige
Maybe the only person brave enough to publicly call Susan Boyle as she sees her (though she later apologized for the “virus” dig) can finally take Randy Jackson to task for his nonsensical commentary. (It’s mad pitchy, dawg!)

Christian Bale Instead of directing his rage at family members and the crew on film sets, the Dark Knight could fight the real enemy: hideously untalented Idol wannabees.

Conan O’Brien Not that he needs the money after his fat severance package from NBC, but I’m getting the giggles just thinking of the witty repartee between Ellen and the short-lived Tonight Show host.

Joan Rivers Since we’re considering professional funny people. I get the feeling that Joan doesn’t really know a thing about music, but despite having a songwriting pedigree, neither does Kara. As long as Joan promises not to bring her daughter Melissa along for the ride.

Naomi Campbell It would be as good for her as it would be for Idol. The anger-management flunkee and former aspiring pop idol (remember Baby Woman?) would have to think of non-violent ways to express her disdain for stinky Idol contestants.

Russell Crowe If Campbell is unavailable, what about her fellow expert in assault with a deadly communication device?

Mel B Admit it: You only care about Victoria Beckham because she’s David’s other half. She was always the dullest Spice Girl, and she still got to guest judge twice during the season-nine auditions. Next season, Idol would be much better off taking a chance on the scariest Spice of all, Melanie Brown.

Wilhelmina Slater Now that both Vanessa Williams and Wilhelmina are out of work, why not hire Williams to reprise her bitch-on-heels Ugly Betty alter ego on Idol? Throw in Michael Urie as her evil-genius sidekick Marc St. James, and I’m so there.


2 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    Some really good ideas here!
    Love Rosie O’Donnell and Conan O’Brien . . . although Conan will no doubt be working again v. soon!
    How about Diddy? He would certainly be entertaining.
    I love JC Chasez on America’s Best Dance Crew . . . and I think Usher could be fantastic in the vein (and his discovery, Justin Bieber, is doing v. well).
    Aside: Isn’t it interesting that American Idol signed up Randy Jackson in the first place? If anyone at Fox had a crystal ball and could forsee AI’s mega-success, he would have never have been hired.

    • collapse expand

      Diddy is not a bad idea! But didn’t you find JC a bit too Paula on America’s Best Dance Crew? I mean, he was definitely more coherent than Paula, but he always seemed to be straining to find something nice to say.
      Hopefully, Usher has a few more hits left in him, so he doesn’t have to do Idol just yet — unless it’s as a mentor.
      You are so right about Randy. What I don’t understand is why they keep renewing his contract! I get that they gave Kara another season because it’s hard to admit you made a mistake, but it’s time to give Randy the boot.

      In response to another comment. See in context »
Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    Ten Things About Me

    1. I was born in the U.S. Virgin Islands and moved to Florida when I was 4, but I've never been able to get rid of my Caribbean accent. When I was a kid and just wanted to fit in, I hated it. Now that I don't, I hope I never lose it. Not that anyone in Buenos Aires even notices it!

    2. I've been a writer and editor for People, Teen People, Us Weekly and Entertainment Weekly.

    3. My favorite city is London, and my favorite country is Italy. I hate Athens, Paris and Berlin.

    4. I once made Brandy's mother cry.

    5. I'm probably one of the few people on earth who can say I stood up a former Beatle. It was Ringo Starr, and I only did it because traffic through Central Park to the Upper East Side was so bad that I showed up to our interview 30 minutes late.

    6. My favorite band of all time is the Smiths. R.E.M. is second. The Cure is my third. I cried when Tammy Wynette, my favorite singer ever, died.

    7. "Atlas Shrugged" by Ayn Rand is my favorite book. I know it's cliché to say, but it changed my life -- not as a political or social manifesto, but as a personal one. What lessons did it teach me? Two: 1) To thine own self be true. 2) Just do it.

    8. "The Golden Girls" is my favorite TV show. I've seen every episode a billion times, but every time I watch one, I notice something I never noticed before.

    9. "Blue" is my favorite movie, and its star, Juliette Binoche is my favorite actress. When she won the Oscar for "The English Patient," all my friends called to congratulate me. By the way, I hated "The English Patient."

    10. At one point, I was doing so much on-air pop-culture commentary that when I walked into Mary J. Blige's hotel suite to interview her, she hugged me and exclaimed, "I've been seeing you all over the TV!" "Likewise!" I replied!

    See my profile »
    Followers: 71
    Contributor Since: May 2009
    Location:Buenos Aires

    What I'm Up To

    My personal blog

    Theme For Great Cities