What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.
 

Nov. 9 2009 - 9:17 pm | 836 views | 0 recommendations | 8 comments

Cohen’s comeback stalls

Sasha Cohen

Sasha Cohen

On Monday morning, Sasha Cohen announced her withdrawal from this week’s Skate America. Cohen has been battling tendinitis in her right calf and was absent at her first event of the season, Trophee Bompard. Over the past few weeks, Cohen’s reportedly been rehabilitating her injury and recently announced her decision to train with former coach John Nicks in Aliso Viejo, California.

Cohen’s withdrawal from Skate America was predicted by nearly everyone in the skating world. Cohen’s critics have chosen to believe that this injury is acting as a convenient excuse for a skater who isn’t prepared to face international competition and never planned on competing in her fall events. Cohen’s fans, on the other hand, see this injury as a side effect of her extensive training for this important Olympic season. Unfortunately, after two withdrawals it’s realistic to think that even the most loyal Sasha fans have to see this week’s announcement as something that doesn’t portend well for Cohen’s chances at Nationals.

Assuming the critics are wrong and Cohen’s injury is justifiable, one can’t assume that after dealing with such a serious injury, Cohen is going to have a great showing in January. An injury like tendinitis needs time to heal, and the best medicine for such a strain is to take a substantial amount of time away from the ice. It doesn’t appear that Cohen‘s done this (and if she has, she shouldn‘t have waited until today to announce her withdrawal), and with the season in full swing, Cohen doesn’t have time to significantly pause her on-ice training.

Tendinitis, of all things, doesn’t guarantee Cohen will be 100% by the time Nationals rolls around. Tendinitis isn’t like a clean fracture. With an injury like tendinitis, pain is persistent and doesn’t come with a set timeline for recovery. Cohen’s not going to be a serious threat to medal if her calf is hurting every time she takes off and lands a jump. A sore calf will cause a skater to tweak their technique in order to avoid pain. When taking off for a triple lutz or flip, a ton of pressure is put on a skater’s calf when they pick in. If they are in any way wary of putting pressure on that part of their leg, they may avoid picking in with the force needed to get the height and rotation on the jump. In recent Grand Prixs, we’ve seen even the slightest underrotations have really hurt a skater’s score. Adding to this, Cohen’s injury comes on her landing leg, and the force generated in the air puts a ton of pressure on the ankle and lower leg once a skater hits the ice. Cohen’s been known to two-foot landings in the past, and with the potential for pain on both her landing and takeoff, mistakes become far more likely.

Cohen has said that the main reason behind her two withdrawals was that the tendinitis has limited her ability to train triple flip and lutzes. Unfortunately, these are two of the most important and difficult jumps for Cohen, serving as her biggest opponents in Torino when she missed both in her long program. Cohen’s often struggled with an inside edge takeoff on her triple lutz, and under the current judging system it’s imperative that Cohen fix that error if she wants to contend for Olympic gold. However, when facing limited training on her triple lutz, it’s unlikely improvements will be made.

Whenever an athlete is dealing with an injury, the setbacks they experience go beyond the physical limitations presented by the injury. There’s also the unfortunate hit in confidence that an athlete has to contend with. Anyone in Cohen’s position would have to be extremely confident in their abilities in order to come back after a four-year absence and believe they have what it takes to make a third Olympic team. Cohen’s errors in past competitions have shown that self-confidence and focus aren‘t her strengths as a competitor. Without the constant repetition and runthroughs needed to feel secure before a big event, it’s expected that Cohen’s confidence will be even more diluted as she begins her quest to win a second Olympic medal.

Along with this, even if Cohen is fully recovered by Nationals and her injury isn’t as debilitating as it appears, making her season debut in January isn’t optimal. In September, Cohen said she was planning to use the Grand Prix as “practice” before Nationals, viewing the U.S. Championships as her true test this season. Debuting two new programs for the first time in front of a panel of judges is never easy. For this reason, many skaters choose to compete in local competitions during the summer months, so they can get any jitters and mistakes out of the way before events that really count. Without the mileage of two Grand Prix events, Cohen doesn’t have that luxury. She will have to show up in Spokane as ready and confident as skaters who’ve had numerous runthroughs and performances under their belts this season.

When you take all of these variables into consideration, even accepting that Cohen’s injury is authentic, you have to see that someone projecting Cohen as the frontrunner at Nationals and a potential Olympic medalist is making an emotional and fanatical claim and isn’t doing it based on empirical evidence. If I were to say that there’s a new skater whose been away from competitive skating for almost four years, has missed her fall competitions because of an injury and is coming to Nationals with two new programs and a history of inconsistency, would you expect this person to be a threat? Probably not.

Sasha Cohen may prove us all wrong, but with all these unfortunate hurdles to overcome, Cohen’s comeback may be over before it even began.


Comments

Active Conversation
3 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 8 Total Comments
Post your comment »
 
  1. collapse expand

    I hope she gets better! She’s one of my favorites!

  2. collapse expand

    The USFSA has known for quite some time that Sasha would not be skating at Skate America. They chose to milk the publicity for as long as they possibly could.

    From all accounts, Sasha does have programs, dresses and even pulls off triple-triples in practice. She is also as inconsistent as ever.

  3. collapse expand

    I would be highly surprised if Cohen makes it to Vancouver as an Olympian. But, who knows, maybe she’ll use this doubt about her to fuel her??

  4. collapse expand

    Great article, Jennifer.

    Well, I’d say there’s some good news and some bad news.

    The bad news: We may not get to see Sasha compete at all this year.

    The good news: She has plenty of time to rest before 2014. ;) (I wonder if USFS already set the date for that press conference? “Sasha to eat sushi in Soshi.” :lol: )

  5. collapse expand

    Hey Jenny…Ive been reading your articles for a while but never commented…just wanted to first commend you on being very on point and insightful!…and good job on COC commentary as well…when are you going to do commentary again?
    Ok so regarding sasha’s jumps…If she can’t land lutz and flips due to her injury, do you think it will be wise for her to do 2 3loops and 2 3sals in the program and then put 3 2axels in there too? I mean if she can do these really well she will get +GOE’s and look at Kiira Korpi..she got quite good score even when she didnt land lutz and didnt have flip or toes and also popped 1 3sal in her long at COC. Sasha’s jump layout can be something like
    3loop2toe2toe
    3loop
    3sal2toe
    3sal
    2axel2axel sequence
    2axel
    3toe
    in any order…what do you think? And also, does her injury affect takeoff or 3loop too? I’m not a skater so I don’t really know. Thank you!! :)

    • collapse expand

      Thank you! With an injured right calf, it seems Sasha would experience pain every time she landed regardless of what jump she was attempting. There’s a ton of force put on a skater’s landing leg, and the injury would probably affect her triple loop takeoff as well. (For a “righty” jumper, a solid triple loop is dependent on a strong vault from their right leg.) That said, from what Sasha’s said it appears she doesn’t experience as much pain on her loop, toe, and sal, so it would be smart for her to focus on those elements and complete a program like the one you mapped out above. Although this would be a wise plan, and if skated cleanly would probably keep her in the top five at Nationals, I don’t see Sasha doing this.

      In response to another comment. See in context »
  6. collapse expand

    Since we’re all engaging in a bit of conjecture here, please indulge me with mine. You’re right that this much-trumpeted comeback is unlikely to materialize. But what’s truly sad here is not that Sasha may not be able to compete, whatever the reason. It would have been nothing short of a miracle if she did. But we have to consider why she felt compelled to even try.

    No doubt she’s smart enough to realize that even if she competed successfully and made the Olympic team, she wouldn’t be competitive with the likes of Yu-na Kim. Since she’s an Olympian already, and a popular one at that, she had nothing to prove. I can only surmise that with professional skating opportunities vanishing, an attempted comeback, even if unsuccessful, can become a skater’s only means of regaining publicity. I’m neither bashing Sasha if that was her motivation (which I don’t know), nor supporting her choice. I’m just sad to see our sport in such dire straights. I suspect that if skating still supported tours like Champions on Ice and professional competitions, skaters like Cohen, Lambiel and Plushenko would see no reason to risk so much for so little.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook
 

My T/S Activity Feed

 
     

    About Me

    I’m originally from Boston, living in LA, with a passion for the world of figure skating. During my career on the ice, I was a world junior champion, a five-time U.S. national medalist, and a three-time world team member. Since retiring from the sport, I have dedicated myself to attaining my college degree with a major in broadcast journalism. I’m looking forward to sharing my views on the ins and outs of the skating world, along with my opinions and thoughts on various issues coming from the ice. I welcome you to my blog!

    To contact me: Jeki815@gmail.com

    See my profile »
    Followers: 115
    Contributor Since: June 2009
    Location:Los Angeles, CA