Carlos Zambrano switch to bullpen should be lesson for Cubs chairman Tom Ricketts
For those reading this post distant from Chicago, you cannot believe the lather the city is in with the switch of Carlos Zambrano to the eighth-inning setup role that no other Cub has been qualified to fill so far in 2010.
You’d think they were coming to take Lou Piniella away to a rest home, with all the fans and media who believe Sweet Lou is nuts for making the change. Of course, so few are well-versed in baseball history, so they don’t remember the long line of prominent starters being switched to the bullpen (yo, Dennis Eckersley and John Smoltz) or relievers being called upon to start.
At the same time, the frothy crowd does not realize the implications of Zambrano filling a role not addressed coming into the season — and which was so apparent to anyone with half a baseball brain analyzing the Cubs. Big Z lumbering in for the eighth should be a nice shot across the bow to new Cubs chairman Tom Ricketts. You want to compete with the big boys, you’ll have to spend like one and you cannot slap on a budget ceiling.
The Zambrano move is the end of a chain of falling dominoes that has padlocked Ricketts’ wallet on the issues of the payroll and flexibility of GM Jim Hendry to trade. Let’s start from the beginning, in the middle of the last decade:
–The Cubs fail to fulfill World Series predictions when Kerry Wood and Mark Prior get hurt, and the Cubs cough up a sure wild-card berth, in 2004.
–Cubs president Andy MacPhail confirms in July 2005 what many had long suspected: he spends far less than he needs to, he prefers that his front office be understaffed, had the wrong philosophy for player development in over-emphasizing pitching, and that he is too arch-conservative to run a successful big-market baseball team. A year later, his Tribune Co. masters conclude the same thing and ask him to resign at the end of the 2006 season. Meanwhile, constant Wood and Prior injuries cause the Cubs to crater by ‘06.
–Trying to correct MacPhail’s penury in one fell swoop, his successors mandate massive overspending on free agents starting with Alfonso Soriano in the winter of 2006-07. The honchos had no choice with the post-World Series White Sox a viable alternative for fans and sponsors, and few position-player prospects in sight to fill holes in the lineup. The strategy might have worked if the Cubs, dramatically improved in winning back-to-back NL Central titles in 2007-08, hadn’t been swept out of the playoffs in six straight games both seasons rather than reaching a Fall Classic, and thus making the hundreds of millions spent palatable.
–In attempting to fix a perceived flaw of too-little left-handed hitting after 2008, with the team for sale and Tribune Co. in bankruptcy, the Cubs are forced to jettison closer Kerry Wood (along with the heartthrob Mark DeRosa) because he’s due for a big raise, and in order to sign Milton Bradley. Wood’s departure leaves a hole in the bullpen, new closer Kevin Gregg doesn’t fill it and Bradley disrupts the entire organization with his wacky, anti-social behavior.
–Ricketts closes the deal to buy the Cubs after the 2009 season, but is saddled with big debt-service payments into the foreseeable future. He has to raise ticket prices in a recession to fund improvements to Wrigley Field. There is no extra money to boost the payroll and either sign a free-agent reliever or trade for the same.
–The Cubs open the 2010 season with too many inexperienced relievers to bridge the innings gap from the starters to Carlos Marmol, finally promoted to closer. Veteran lefty John Grabow, overexposed in the eighth, is pounded. The predictable occurs with a series of eighth-inning collapses in the season’s first two weeks.
–Desperate times call for desperate measures, so Zambrano is tapped to fill the setup job. Ryan Dempster already had been a failed closer. Carlos Silva and Tom Gorzelanny can’t handle late-inning relief. Randy Wells is fine where he is as a sinker-balling-type starter. Big Z wins by process of elimination.
It’s difficult to tie MacPhail’s old-fashioned, skinflint philosophy to Ricketts’ own financial power or lack of the same. But past is prologue in baseball, the most timeless game of them all.
I hope Ricketts, a good person along with his fellow owner-siblings, is learning a lesson. You can apportion untold millions to buy a team and spruce up antiquated facilities. Yet for every dollar you budget, you better add at least another 25 cents. There will be cost overruns and cleanups of past mistakes that go back more than a half-decade. You cannot freeze expenditures or raise money from the fans, who are at the breaking point about what they can continue to afford to pay.
The brand-new Cubs players lounge and weight room, along with the fresh paint all over the ballpark, were years late in being instituted. Urinals in the men’s room with dividers on each side were necessary for the bashful among us who cannot abide the famed troughs. The promotion of the new bison burgers and hot dogs, some of the meat coming from the Ricketts family bison ranch in Wyoming, was a nice touch, particularly on the first Thursday of the year when the media had a free lunch with the entire new menu, including bison chili, available for taste-testing.
But first, above everything else, is attention to the roster. Patchwork and desperation is not the right way to run a flagship franchise like the Cubs. Next season, Tom Ricketts ought to know his funding has to be properly lined up before Hendry, or whomever, starts filling out the player ranks.


















See Older Posts


