What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Sep. 14 2009 - 9:11 pm | 11 views | 1 recommendation | 9 comments

New York City Primary Primer

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg opening ...

Image via Wikipedia

It’s chic to bemoan the anemic voter turnout localities experience in off-year elections. Without a President (or even Congress) to vote for, the electorate generally doesn’t show up to cast their opinion about the politicians that matter most to their day-to-day lives. Pundits whine about this, but pundits also spend an inordinate amount of time talking about national issues while neglecting the local matters happening in their own communities.

Well, not me. Instead of kvetching about those that don’t care about local politics, I’m going to embrace those that do. Sadly, I only live in one locality. But it is an exciting one. Here in New York City, we practice a brand of in-your-face, apartment block politicking that the mainstream media thinks only happens once every four years in New Hampshire.

I encourage all of you to find the interesting details of the local elections in your communities. Let’s dive right into all of the electioneering glory that determines how the greatest city on Earth is governed.  I’ll share my ballot with you after the jump.

For those who have not yet been immersed in and besmirched by NYC politics, let me give you some ground rules:

1. Primary Day is where it’s at. Don’t let the spate of non-Democratic mayors fool you, Democrats outnumber Republicans in NYC like mice outnumber people. Most general elections in the city are mere formalities.

2. “Identity Politics” in NYC isn’t a dirty phrase. It’s how we roll. These are local elections, where issue platforms are very similar. If you have a mustache and you vote for the guy with the mustache, you should congratulate yourself for knowing which candidate sports a mustache and move on.

Now that the set up is out of the way, let’s look at the key races this election season.

Bill de Blasio v. Eric Gioia v. Mark Green v. Norman Siegel

Technically, the Public Advocate has a city-wide constituency and is supposed to be kind of a good government watchdog over all of city government. The Public Advocate is also the person who assumes power in the Mayor’s absence, death, or resignation. Some argue that it’s the second most powerful position in the city. It is definitely a stepping stone for a future mayoral campaign.

Practically, it probably means more to the average New Yorker to have a reliable weed connection than a strong Public Advocate. The position holds no legislative or executive power. When you have a powerful mayor and a pliable city council, the Public Advocate could be a cardboard cutout for all anyone would notice. Anything the Public Advocate can do for the people will be dependent on his or her relationship with the mayor and the council.

And that’s what makes this year’s race so interesting. It really comes down to whether New Yorkers want a vocal PA that is going to get into the face of a mayor — or at least compete with the mayor in the press. Or if we want somebody who is going to quietly work with Mayor Bloomberg to get done what they can. You could have somebody calling out the mayor and raising the profile of issues, or you can have somebody working behind the scenes with the mayor to make incremental changes. Both are valid uses of the office.

Mark Green served as Public Advocate during “Giuliani time.” He ran against Bloomberg back in 2001. Green was winning that race, before the tragic events of September 11th. Green still thinks he should be mayor. He doesn’t want this job to play nicely with others. Strategically, Green has a huge advantage in name recognition.

Bill de Blasio tallBill de Blasio is a well respected City Councilman. He is arguing that he can work with Bloomberg as he has done on the City Council. De Blasio received the endorsement of the New York Times, and former New York Governor Mario Cuomo. Those endorsements were key considering Mark Green’s heavy advantage in name recognition. De Blasio is also almost monstrously tall (in the picture, he’s on the left dwarfing Green and Gioia).  I’m sure that makes it difficult for him to find appropriately sized pants. But when you meet him out on the campaign trail, you remember him.

And then there’s City Councilman Eric Gioia. He is running as the proverbial “outsider” for a position that only insiders truly understand. While de Blasio and Green sling mud back and forth, Gioia is running as the clean alternative. He has put a ton of money into this campaign with television ads.

Norman Siegel is always running for something. He doesn’t win anything.

If one candidate doesn’t achieve at least 40% of the vote, there is a runoff election.

There is a lot to like about this race. There are a couple of different theories about how to conduct “loyal opposition” that the different candidates embody.

Elie’s Pick:  Bill de Blasio

Why? Mark Green is the only man with a chance to avoid a runoff. But Green’s had his time. Right now the race is for second place. Like many old school New York Democrats, I tend to do what Mario Cuomo tells me to do.  And I don’t need a Public Advocate whose only purpose is to slow Bloomberg down, that is still supposed to be the job of the City Council.

Melinda Katz v. John C. Liu v. David I. Weprin v. David Yassky

The winner of this race is going to be in a very strong position come the 2013 mayoral election. If the New York economy recovers, the Comptroller can claim he or she was Bloomberg’s right hand financial helper.

But the prospects for this race producing a future mayor are perhaps even greater if the economy tanks. That’s because New York City Council Speaker Christine Quinn has essentially hitched her political future to the successes of Mike Bloomberg. Her City Council seems to go out of its way to roll over for the mayor. Any Bloomberg weaknesses are going to be Quinn weaknesses. If things are still tough four years from now, the city will be looking for an anti-Bloomberg, but it will still want somebody with a command understanding of city finances.

With that in mind, I present Brooklyn City Councilman David Yassky. The man rolls into Tuesday with endorsements from The New York Times and The Daily News. He’s got Senator Charles Schumer shooting campaign commercials for him, and he has the endorsement of Russell Simmons. Yes, the Def Comedy Jam guy. He’s got a law degree from Yale — and on a personal note, I’ve seen him or his people campaigning in my Upper East Side neighborhood more than the people who are running for mayor this year.

David Weprin with mustacheBut this race is far from over. Fighting out of the Queens, Councilman David Weprin is rocking some high profile endorsements (and an elite mustache) of his own. Former NYC Mayor David Dinkins is on board. So is Fernando Ferrer — last seen trying to dislodge Mike Bloomberg’s loafers from his body cavities.

John Liu is lighter on endorsements. But he’s the one that is actually winning this race, according to the latest polls. He also has some color to his campaign, and a little melanin too. His city council election was the first time an Asian-American was elected to a city office in New York. He has a compelling personal story — which includes a campaign claim that he worked in a sweatshop when he was seven-years-old to help pay the bills. Some have questioned the veracity of his “sweatshop” claim, but for what it’s worth, I believe Mr. Liu.

Melinda Katz is quite consciously trying to pull the female vote. And she says the word “tough” so many times in her her ads that I’m now convinced she could kick my butt in a street fight. But more importantly, at times she seems like the only one who is running for Comptroller in 2009, instead of mayor in 2013. She’s running second and good government types might want to give her a second look.

Elie’s Pick:  David Yassky

Why? If I were voting for Comptroller, I’d vote for Liu. There’s something about growing up poor yet controlling the city’s money that I find appealing. However, I’m not voting for Comptroller. I’m voting for the person most likely to end the Democratic drought at City Hall in 2013. Right now, that appears to be Mr. Yassky.

Bill Thompson v. Tony Avella v. Roland Rogers

This is the least interesting primary because Michael Bloomberg is going to win in the general. And it’s not going to be close. Remember, at this point 2/3rds of New Yorkers have seen a Re-Elect Bloomberg ad. Many have seen so many of them that they find the commercials annoying, but isn’t that how advertising works? I mean, I have a strong feeling that I should switch my car insurance to Geico — and I don’t own a car.

Bloomberg was supposed to be term limited out of office this year. But after he decided not to run for President, and after the markets collapsed, he changed the law so he could run for a third term. The City Council went along with it (City Council = people who want additional terms too). With Bloomberg entrenched, many potential Democratic challengers decided to opt out of this year’s mayoral race.

All of these guys that remain should be docked points for refusing to take advantage of the mercy rule. But, electoral formalities being what they are in a republic, let’s look at the challengers.

Bill Thompson Tony AvellaBill Thompson is the current New York City Comptroller. Thompson looked like a strong candidate for mayor. He’s black, the Comptroller race proved he could win citywide elected office, and his financial background seemed like a good fit as the city confronted the Wall Street collapse.

Tony Avella is a City Councilman who also worked for former mayors Ed Koch and David Dinkins. He’s been running as the guy most likely to beat Bloomberg. He’s certainly more likely to beat Bloomberg than I am. But neither of us are going to be mayor next year, so what is his point exactly?

Also there’s this guy named Roland Rogers. He’s in the race so that next time somebody says “Roland Rogers,” an average New Yorker might say something other than “who?” Good luck with that Mr … Whoever!

Elie’s Pick: Bill Thompson.

Why? In a general election match up with Mayor Bloomberg, Thompson leads Bloomberg 48% to 39% among African-American voters (Thompson is getting killed in all other demographics). To put that stat another way, the black guy isn’t pulling more than 50% of the black vote in New York City. That. Is. Embarrassing.  I don’t believe that number will hold up, so I’ve got to give Thompson a chance to improve on that number by the time the general rolls around.

Hope you enjoyed my romp through local primary season. Don’t forget to vote.



Active Conversation
9 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    Thanks for this but you stopped too soon! Who do I vote for for DA?

    • collapse expand

      I kind of disagree as a matter of general principle that D.A.’s should be elected … but I skipped over the DA race because I wanted to keep it under 2,000 words.

      I’m going with Cy Vance. Leslie Crocker Snyder used to be a judge, and in that roll seemed to relish punishing drug dealers — above and beyond the minimums. I get how the law and order types like that stuff. I think the city has much bigger criminals than drug dealers.

      Also, Snyder’s main criticism of Vance is that he “left the city” to “defend criminals” in Seattle. But I like Vance’s answer for this. Essentially, he said that he had a famous father and wanted to make his own name for himself so he went as far away as he could and tried to make it. Instead of just riding on Daddy’s coattails, I like how Vance went out west — and I don’t reflexively hate criminal defense attorneys.

      So, that’s my pick.

      In response to another comment. See in context »
  2. collapse expand

    how we “role?” your ATL following is going to be all over you for that.

    Nice article.

  3. collapse expand

    For awhile I had trouble deciding between Vance and Snyder. I didn’t like the campaign she ran, I didn’t like the fact she put gender issue at forefront of her campaign and I didn’t like the fact she went negative with her ads last week.

  4. collapse expand


    Oh, for anybody that happens upon this post, turnout for the above discussed primary was a record … low.

    Oh well. Runoff in two weeks!

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    My first name is pronounced like Eliot without the “it,” my last name is pronounced like the Crystal I don’t have the “M”oney to afford. I’m an editor of Above the Law, a legal website that covers all of the gossip and business of the legal profession. Prior to that I wrote about politics. I used to be a lawyer, but I quit that profession in lieu of stripping naked and lighting myself on fire. I received a degree in Government from Harvard University because I enjoy pain, and a J.D. from Harvard Law School because I dislike change. I’m also a Met fan (pain + born in Queens).

    I’m African-American thanks to my maternal grandmother (which means there is one word I can use that white people can’t. Mwahaha). My father is from Haiti and my wife is from Zimbabwe, but outside of the northeast corridor I turn into a sniveling idiot. My maternal grandfather is from China, so I can make fun of Chinese-Americans ¼ of the time. It’d be great to go a whole year without embarrassing my mother, as Julia might say “Ye Gods, can that woman wait.”

    See my profile »
    Followers: 154
    Contributor Since: May 2009