What Is True/Slant?
275+ knowledgeable contributors.
Reporting and insight on news of the moment.
Follow them and join the news conversation.

Jun. 10 2010 - 10:31 am | 782 views | 0 recommendations | 4 comments

Teen Mom Charged With Manslaughter After Her Dogs Kill Her Infant

Sleep Like A Baby

Image by peasap via Flickr

This is the news story right now in Quebec, (in addition to the Grand Prix in Montreal), a terrible tale of a teen mom who stepped outside two days ago for a cigarette — to protect her newborn from second-hand smoke — in which time her two huskies attacked and killed the child. She lives in a small town about 40 miles east of Montreal.

She has already been charged with manslaughter by the Crown Attorney, (Canada’s version of a DA), prompting howls of outrage in the Gazette letters page and even an editorial in the Toronto-based, national Globe and Mail:

Parents who make mistakes are probably the norm, rather than an exception. Momentary lapses are common. Sometimes, babies and small children die as a result. They fall into hot tubs and drown. They wade out beyond their competence into lakes and drown. They fall off farm machinery. They are asphyxiated when sharing a bed with a parent. They fall out of windows.

It is rare that charges of manslaughter are laid in those deaths. Manslaughter requires a foreseeable risk of injury, and a marked departure from the standard of reasonable person. “The momentary lapse that a reasonable person would engage in is not meant to be caught by the criminal law,” says Sanjeev Anand, a law professor at the University of Alberta Law School. A marked departure implies gross negligence – “the absolutely egregious conduct that no reasonable person would engage in.”

There is some dispute about the facts…Her family says she was outside briefly; the police concluded after a short investigation (they charged her one day after the death) that she was outside for 20 minutes…

The state does not need to exact justice every time a child dies an accidental death, even where a parental lapse in judgment led to it. A grieving mother now needs to defend herself against a charge that her wrongful conduct killed her own baby. For a parent, the death of a baby is an excruciating punishment from which there is no parole. In the circumstances of this case, it is hard to see how laying a manslaughter charge serves the public interest.

Several of the letters in the Montreal Gazette raise the question of the mother’s age and likely low ncome — if she were 25 or 35, not 17 — would she have been charged, and so quickly?



2 T/S Member Comments Called Out, 4 Total Comments
Post your comment »
  1. collapse expand

    Ah yes. It’s good to see our brand of thoughtless, knee-jerk authoritarianism-for-the-sake-of-authority has spread to our neighbor to the north. Good for them.

  2. collapse expand

    The saddest thing in the world is when a baby dies, in my town a woman has just been arrested for smothering her infant son over the holiday weekend. And even in that case, there were extenuating circumstances involving the mother’s state of mind and her depression. In both of these cases, I find myself grieving for the babies and the mothers. They say that the law is justice without reason, but in cases like these I personally believe it is vital for the judiciary to apply reason in order to arrive at the least worst outcome. Should the teen mom in your story, who’s life has already be decimated, be subjected to additional punitive damages? Should the mom in my story, a woman already suicidal and grieving, be brought even lower?

    Don’t get me wrong, there are certainly cases where the laws that ostensibly designed to protect children should be vigorously applied. But justice cannot be applied without reason, and when a tragedy occurs we shouldn’t try to make up for it with more justice.

  3. collapse expand

    It has happened here with a shocking degree of speed, given how slowly the wheels of justice turn in other cases. The first reports only came out two days ago at 3pm — and now she’s charged.

    It is terrifying to me that what appears to have been an error could result in prosecution. It’s no less devastating to a 17 year old (who, arguably) might have poorer judgment than to an older woman.

  4. collapse expand

    I think this is really sad, horrible situation. I have a four month old and I have two dogs I too step outside the door to smoke but I usually take the dogs with me or put my son in his crib or bounce. My dogs are also very well trained they know not to get close to my son or there will be spankings. I deff would have thought on the type of dogs I had before bringing a newborn home big dogs can accidentally step on the baby and that could result in harm. But what she’s being charged with is a lil crazzy I think because I do understand a baby died she did not do it. Her judgement was off and who’s to say it wasn’t from the baby screaming for hours and she jus needed a break before she couldn’t handel it. Im sure the death of her child will haunt her for the rest of her life that hard enough because she will always blam herself. Saddle accidents happen all the time just sad it caused a death to a child.

Log in for notification options
Comments RSS

Post Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment

Log in with your True/Slant account.

Previously logged in with Facebook?

Create an account to join True/Slant now.

Facebook users:
Create T/S account with Facebook

My T/S Activity Feed


    About Me

    Former reporter and feature writer for the Globe and Mail, Montreal Gazette and the New York Daily News. Winner of a Canadian National Magazine Award (humor) about -- what else -- my divorce. I've been writing frequently for The New York Times since 1990 on almost any subject you can think of -- yup, I'm a generalist. Author of "Blown Away: American Women and Guns" (Pocket Books 2004). Canadian born, raised and formally educated, I've lived in New York since 1989.

    See my profile »
    Followers: 249
    Contributor Since: June 2009
    Location:NYC suburb

    What I'm Up To


    I’m writing my second book, a memoir for Portfolio/Penguin, of working retail in a suburban mall for more than two years. My 11 Reporting Tips from daily newspaper veterans appears in the May issue of The Writer magazine.

    I also coach fellow writers and edit their work.